
Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizza
High-heat oven, 72-hour dough, San Marzano tomatoes — blistered, chewy, and gone in minutes.
Learn more →Pies blistered at 900 degrees — leopard-spotted crust, San Marzano sauce, fresh fior di latte.
Chicken parm, veal marsala, Sunday gravy — the classics your nonna approves of.
Selden's pizza & ristorante
Blistered crusts from a screaming-hot oven, red-sauce classics done right, and a dining room that feels like family — Caffe Amici is Selden's Italian table.
What we do
From everyday favorites to special occasions — this is what Selden keeps coming back for.

High-heat oven, 72-hour dough, San Marzano tomatoes — blistered, chewy, and gone in minutes.
Learn more →
Chicken parm, veal marsala, shrimp scampi, and Sunday gravy over perfectly al dente pasta.
Learn more →
Half and full trays of every favorite — feeds the office, the team, or the whole family reunion.
Learn more →
Big platters, passed around the table, the way Italian dinner is supposed to work.
Learn more →
Hot pies and full dinners to go — call 631-698-0818 and skip the wait.
Learn more →
Gluten-free crusts and pasta so nobody at the table has to sit out pizza night.
Learn more →By the numbers
* Illustrative figures shown for demonstration purposes.
The difference
Drag the handle to compare — this is the Caffe Amici difference.

How it works
Dine in at Independence Plaza or call 631-698-0818 — Friday nights move fast.
Eighteen specialty pies or build your own — the margherita is the benchmark.
Round out the table with parm, marsala, and a house salad built for sharing.
There won't be many. Box up what's left and do it again next week.
Kind words
* Representative guest feedback shown for demonstration.
Good to know
Yes — gluten-free crusts and gluten-free pasta are available, so everyone at the table can join in.
Takeout and delivery are available. Call 631-698-0818 to order — Friday and Saturday evenings are busiest.
Absolutely — half and full trays of pizzas, parms, pastas, and salads for any size event across the Selden area.
The dining room welcomes walk-ins; for parties of six or more, calling ahead at 631-698-0818 is recommended.
Yes — free plaza parking right outside at 353 Independence Plaza.
Open daily for lunch and dinner. Call 631-698-0818 for today's hours and holiday schedules.
Proudly serving
Caffe Amici serves Selden and these surrounding Long Island communities.
Ready when you are
Blistered crusts from a screaming-hot oven, red-sauce classics done right, and a dining room that feels like family — Caffe Amici is Selden's Italian table.