HomeServicesAboutContact Call 631-698-0818
Caffe Amici Pizzeria & Ristorante

Our story

The story behind Caffe Amici

Selden's pizza & ristorante

About us

A Selden original

Caffe Amici Pizzeria & Ristorante is where Selden goes when only real Italian will do. The oven runs screaming hot for true Neapolitan-style pies, the kitchen turns out red-sauce classics the old way, and the dining room runs on the simple belief that nobody should leave hungry.

  • ✓Wood-fired oven for true blistered-crust pizza
  • ✓Full ristorante menu — parm, marsala, scampi, Sunday gravy
  • ✓Catering trays and family-style dinners for any crowd
  • ✓Gluten-free crusts and pasta available
Inside Caffe Amici Pizzeria & Ristorante

By the numbers

Caffe Amici at a glance

0 Years Serving Selden
0 Specialty Pies
0 Menu Favorites
0 Happy Guests Weekly

* Illustrative figures shown for demonstration purposes.

Kind words

What Selden says

★★★★★

“The margherita here ruined every other pizza for me. Crust is perfect — blistered, chewy, gone in four minutes.”

— Pizza loyalist, Selden

★★★★★

“Ordered six party trays for my son's graduation. Everything arrived hot and the chicken parm got demolished.”

— Party host, Centereach

★★★★★

“Our Friday tradition for three years. The staff knows our order before we sit down.”

— Family of five, Farmingville

* Representative guest feedback shown for demonstration.

Ready when you are

Experience Caffe Amici for yourself

Blistered crusts from a screaming-hot oven, red-sauce classics done right, and a dining room that feels like family — Caffe Amici is Selden's Italian table.

Call Now Directions