HomeServicesAboutContact Call 631-698-0818

From the Oven

Pies blistered at 900 degrees — leopard-spotted crust, San Marzano sauce, fresh fior di latte.

The Ristorante

Chicken parm, veal marsala, Sunday gravy — the classics your nonna approves of.

Selden's pizza & ristorante

Pizza Napoletana, Selden Style

Blistered crusts from a screaming-hot oven, red-sauce classics done right, and a dining room that feels like family — Caffe Amici is Selden's Italian table.

Scroll

What we do

Everything Caffe Amici does best

From everyday favorites to special occasions — this is what Selden keeps coming back for.

Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizza

Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizza

High-heat oven, 72-hour dough, San Marzano tomatoes — blistered, chewy, and gone in minutes.

Learn more →
Classic Italian Ristorante

Classic Italian Ristorante

Chicken parm, veal marsala, shrimp scampi, and Sunday gravy over perfectly al dente pasta.

Learn more →
Catering & Party Trays

Catering & Party Trays

Half and full trays of every favorite — feeds the office, the team, or the whole family reunion.

Learn more →
Family-Style Dinners

Family-Style Dinners

Big platters, passed around the table, the way Italian dinner is supposed to work.

Learn more →
Takeout & Delivery

Takeout & Delivery

Hot pies and full dinners to go — call 631-698-0818 and skip the wait.

Learn more →
Gluten-Free Options

Gluten-Free Options

Gluten-free crusts and pasta so nobody at the table has to sit out pizza night.

Learn more →

By the numbers

Caffe Amici at a glance

0 Years Serving Selden
0 Specialty Pies
0 Menu Favorites
0 Happy Guests Weekly

* Illustrative figures shown for demonstration purposes.

The difference

Before & after

Drag the handle to compare — this is the Caffe Amici difference.

Frozen pizza Friday
Friday at Caffe Amici
↔
Before After

How it works

Easy as one, two, three

  1. Call or Walk In

    Dine in at Independence Plaza or call 631-698-0818 — Friday nights move fast.

  2. Pick Your Pie

    Eighteen specialty pies or build your own — the margherita is the benchmark.

  3. Add the Classics

    Round out the table with parm, marsala, and a house salad built for sharing.

  4. Take the Leftovers

    There won't be many. Box up what's left and do it again next week.

Kind words

What Selden says

★★★★★

“The margherita here ruined every other pizza for me. Crust is perfect — blistered, chewy, gone in four minutes.”

— Pizza loyalist, Selden

★★★★★

“Ordered six party trays for my son's graduation. Everything arrived hot and the chicken parm got demolished.”

— Party host, Centereach

★★★★★

“Our Friday tradition for three years. The staff knows our order before we sit down.”

— Family of five, Farmingville

* Representative guest feedback shown for demonstration.

Good to know

Questions, answered

Yes — gluten-free crusts and gluten-free pasta are available, so everyone at the table can join in.

Takeout and delivery are available. Call 631-698-0818 to order — Friday and Saturday evenings are busiest.

Absolutely — half and full trays of pizzas, parms, pastas, and salads for any size event across the Selden area.

The dining room welcomes walk-ins; for parties of six or more, calling ahead at 631-698-0818 is recommended.

Yes — free plaza parking right outside at 353 Independence Plaza.

Open daily for lunch and dinner. Call 631-698-0818 for today's hours and holiday schedules.

Proudly serving

Your neighborhood, our home

Caffe Amici serves Selden and these surrounding Long Island communities.

Ready when you are

Experience Caffe Amici for yourself

Blistered crusts from a screaming-hot oven, red-sauce classics done right, and a dining room that feels like family — Caffe Amici is Selden's Italian table.

Call Now Directions